Cigarettes or Vape: Which is Worse?

Cigarettes or Vape: Which is Worse?

Vaping was once hailed as the “safe alternative to smoking,” with many believing that vaping would have none of the harmful side-effects that come with smoking. However, as more and more research was done, we’ve learned more and more. Vaping is not as harmless as you may have been lead to believe. Is vaping more addictive than cigarettes?

To help you gain a better understanding, this article will review the basics of nicotine, the drug that makes cigarettes and smoking so addictive. Then, we’ll look at the science behind vaping addiction and the effects that that addiction has on adolescents.

Understanding Addiction: Nicotine and Beyond

To answer this question, it's crucial to understand the addictive properties of nicotine. Nicotine is a highly addictive substance found in both traditional cigarettes and e-cigarettes. When inhaled, nicotine quickly enters the bloodstream and stimulates the release of dopamine, a neurotransmitter associated with pleasure and reward. This rapid dopamine release creates a pleasurable sensation, reinforcing the desire to repeat the behavior.

While both vaping and smoking deliver nicotine to the user, there are specific factors unique to vaping that may contribute to its perceived addictive potential. For instance, the inclusion of nicotine salts or protonated nicotine in e-cigarettes facilitates easier inhalation and increases nicotine delivery to the bloodstream.

This method of nicotine delivery enhances the user experience, potentially leading to a higher addiction liability compared to traditional cigarettes. The question of "is vaping more addictive than cigarettes" is thus a critical one, as the ease of use and higher nicotine absorption rates associated with vaping devices might make them more addictive.

Additionally, the wide availability of appealing flavors in vaping products can attract younger users, who might be more susceptible to addiction. This further complicates the issue of whether "is vaping more addictive than cigarettes," as the enticing flavors combined with the efficient nicotine delivery system could lead to increased usage and dependency, especially among adolescents and young adults.

The potential for vaping to be more addictive than traditional cigarettes underscores the need for more research and regulatory measures aimed at understanding and mitigating the risks associated with these devices.

The Science behind Vaping Addiction

Nicotine Delivery and Addiction Liability

A study published in the journal JAMA Network Open examined the addiction patterns among more than 151,000 American children in grades six to twelve between 2014 and 2021. The findings revealed that e-cigarettes were more addictive than traditional cigarettes. Some school-age users reported vaping within five minutes of waking up, indicating a higher level of addiction compared to their peers who smoked conventional cigarettes.

The introduction of protonated nicotine in e-liquids has been attributed to this heightened addiction potential. By lowering the acidity of nicotine, e-cigarettes make it easier to inhale and deliver nicotine more efficiently. Consequently, the changes in addiction patterns observed in the study may be linked to the increased levels of nicotine delivery associated with modern e-cigarettes.

Factors Influencing Vaping Addiction

While nicotine plays a significant role in addiction, other factors contribute to the addictive nature of vaping. These factors include a person's environment, social and family settings, mental health, coping mechanisms, and individual susceptibility to addiction. This is crucial to understand when making the comparison and asking the question “is vaping more addictive than cigarettes.”

Cravings associated with addiction are both physical and mental. People may experience a physical desire for nicotine, but their brains also form habitual associations between certain settings or activities and the act of vaping. These environmental cues can trigger cravings and contribute to the cycle of addiction.

Emotions also play a role in addiction. Vaping may serve as a coping mechanism for individuals experiencing stress, sadness, or anxiety. The association between emotional discomfort and vaping can reinforce the addictive behavior by providing temporary relief and triggering the release of feel-good hormones like dopamine and serotonin.

Marketing and Ease of Use

The marketing and advertising strategies employed by e-cigarette companies have also been identified as factors contributing to vaping addiction. Companies like Juul and Myle Vape have faced criticism for their marketing practices, raising concerns about their impact on youth and the potential for addiction.

Additionally, the ease of use offered by e-cigarettes, particularly devices like Juul, has made them more accessible and appealing to individuals, including young users. The simplicity of puffing on a device compared to the process of lighting a traditional cigarette and finding a designated smoking area has removed barriers and made vaping more convenient. This makes answering the question of “is vaping more addictive than cigarettes” difficult due to the relative ease of vaping vs smoking a cigarette.

The Impact on Adolescents

Vulnerability and Brain Development

One of the most significant concerns surrounding vaping addiction is its impact on adolescents. Adolescents' brains are still developing, making them more susceptible to the addictive effects of nicotine. The prefrontal cortex, responsible for critical skills such as memory, reward processing, and logic, is particularly vulnerable to the damaging effects of nicotine during this developmental phase.

The study mentioned earlier found that the age at which individuals initiate e-cigarette use has decreased, while the intensity of use and addiction have increased. By 2019, more e-cigarette users were using their first tobacco product within five minutes of waking up compared to users of traditional cigarettes.

This trend highlights the need for clinicians to address youth addiction to highly addictive nicotine products and emphasizes the importance of comprehensive regulations, including bans on flavored tobacco products.

Impact of the COVID-19 Pandemic

The COVID-19 pandemic has further complicated the issue of vaping addiction among adolescents. The isolation and stress associated with the pandemic may have led to an increased use of nicotine for self-medication in response to depression, anxiety, and other mental health challenges. The disruption of school-based prevention and treatment efforts during the pandemic also limited access to support and intervention for adolescents struggling with nicotine addiction, making these resources seem passe to a post-pandemic world. Even years alter, we are seeing the impact on our youth.

Conclusion: Addressing Vaping Addiction

In conclusion, while nicotine addiction is a significant concern associated with both vaping and smoking, evidence suggests that vaping may have a higher addictive potential than traditional cigarettes. Factors such as enhanced nicotine delivery, marketing strategies, and ease of use contribute to the addictive nature of vaping. Adolescents are particularly vulnerable to the addictive effects of vaping due to ongoing brain development.

To address the issue of vaping addiction, comprehensive regulations are necessary. Early intervention, prevention efforts, and stronger regulations, such as banning flavored tobacco products, can help mitigate the impact of vaping addiction on young individuals.

It is essential to note that this article is for informational purposes only and does not replace medical advice. If you or someone you know is struggling with nicotine addiction, consult with a healthcare professional for personalized guidance and support.


CAMH: Nicotine Dependence

JPHE: Implications of Vaping

SAMHSA: Adolescence Vaping Survey

The smarter way to stay accountable
Real-time group support and personalized feedback to help you overcome addiction — no matter how many times you’ve tried.
Learn Morean iphone with the text identify where boundaries may have slipped
No items found.
relay logo

Get connected and stay accountable
with peers

Join a team

A better way to recovery, right in your pocket.

a cell phone with a text message on the screen